In our earlier article, we have discussed probability and non-probability sampling, in which we came across types of probability sampling, i.e. Stratified Sampling and Cluster Sampling that are most commonly juxtaposed by the people. There is a big difference between stratified and cluster sampling, which in the first sampling technique, the sample is created out of the random selection of elements from all the strata while in the second method, all the units of the randomly selected clusters form a sample. Similarly, other significant distinguishing points are discussed in the given article. Have a look.
Content: Stratified Sampling Vs Cluster Sampling
|Basis for Comparison||Stratified Sampling||Cluster Sampling|
|Meaning||Stratified sampling is one, in which the population is divided into homogeneous segments, and then the sample is randomly taken from the segments.||Cluster sampling refers to a sampling method wherein the members of the population are selected at random, from naturally occurring groups called 'cluster'.|
|Sample||Randomly selected individuals are taken from all the strata.||All the individuals are taken from randomly selected clusters.|
|Selection of population elements||Individually||Collectively|
|Homogeneity||Within group||Between groups|
|Heterogeneity||Between groups||Within group|
|Bifurcation||Imposed by the researcher||Naturally occurring groups|
|Objective||To increase precision and representation.||To reduce cost and improve efficiency.|
Definition of Stratified Sampling
Stratified sampling is a type of probability sampling, in which first of all the population is bifurcated into various mutually exclusive, homogeneous subgroups (strata), after that, a subject is selected randomly from each group (stratum), which are then combined to form a single sample. A stratum is nothing but a homogeneous subset of the population, and when all the stratum are taken together, it is known as strata.
The common factors in which the population is separated are age, gender, income, race, religion, etc. An important point to remember is that strata should be collectively exhaustive so that no individual is left out and also non-overlapping because overlapping stratum may result in the increase in the selection chances of some population elements. The sub-types of stratified sampling are:
- Proportionate Stratified Sampling
- Disproportionate Stratified Sampling
Definition of Cluster Sampling
Cluster sampling is defined as a sampling technique in which the population is divided into already existing groupings (clusters), and then a sample of the cluster is selected randomly from the population. The term cluster refers to a natural, but heterogeneous, intact grouping of the members of the population. The most common variables used in the clustering population are the geographical area, buildings, school, etc. Heterogeneity of the cluster is an important feature of an ideal cluster sample design. Sub-types of cluster sampling:
- Single-stage cluster sampling
- Two-stage cluster sampling
- Multistage cluster sampling
Key Differences Between Stratified and Cluster Sampling
The differences between stratified and cluster sampling can be drawn clearly on the following grounds:
- A probability sampling procedure in which the population is separated into different homogeneous segments called ‘strata’, and then the sample is chosen from the each stratum randomly, is called Stratified Sampling. Cluster Sampling is a sampling technique in which the units of the population are randomly selected from already existing groups called ‘cluster.’
- In stratified sampling the individuals are randomly selected from all the strata, to constitute the sample. On the other hand cluster sampling, the sample is formed when all the individuals are taken from randomly selected clusters.
- In cluster sampling, population elements are selected in aggregates, however, in the case of stratified sampling the population elements are selected individually from each stratum.
- In stratified sampling, there is homogeneity within the group, whereas in the case of cluster sampling the homogeneity is found between groups.
- Heterogeneity occurs between groups in stratified sampling. On the contrary, the members of the group are heterogeneous in cluster sampling.
- When the sampling method adopted by the researcher is stratified, then the categories are imposed by him. In contrast, the categories are already existing groups in cluster sampling.
- Stratified sampling aims at improving precision and representation. Unlike cluster sampling whose objective is to improve cost effectiveness and operational efficiency.
To end up the discussion, we can say that a preferable situation for stratified sampling is when the identicalness within an individual stratum and the strata mean to vary from each other. On the other hand, the standard situation for cluster sampling is when the diversity within clusters and the cluster should not vary from each other.
Further, sampling errors can be reduced in stratified sampling if between-group differences among strata are increased, whereas the between-group differences among clusters should be minimised to reduce sampling errors in cluster sampling.